From the parish website, "LeBrun [architect] designed the new Trinity Episcopal Church in the English Gothic style. Construction was begun after the thirtieth day of May, 1847, when St. Luke’s Church was taken down. The new church was a tremendous leap of faith for the Parish; it was to have cost ten thousand dollars, but additional costs put the Parish into debt for many years thereafter."

"The new church also received a new organ in 1848. The "…enterprising godly women [of the parish] got up a 'street fair' for the purchase of a new organ, indispensable in so large a church…the fair realized over twelve hundred dollars, [and] the organ was paid for…" (from The Trinity Church Monthly)."